The 6 Best Beginner Prostate Toys for First-Timer Fun

The Billy 2 is an excellent beginner prostate toy. I actually only have one major complaint: it’s not waterproof! This means you’ll need to be a little more careful when cleaning the toy, and obviously, any type of bath or shower play is out of the question. However, if this isn’t a deal-breaker for you then you’re sure to love the Billy 2. With multiple vibration functions & speeds, the toy can go as fast (or as slow) as you need to provide complete satisfaction. Its curved design makes it easy to target your prostate, and the soft silicone is easy to insert. Although it may be a bit expensive, I think the Lelo Billy 2 is a worthwhile investment. Like other Lelo toys, it can be a bit costly, but you definitely get your money’s worth with this purchase!

If you’re looking for a simple beginner prostate toy then the Booty Buddy is surely a top contender. Its simple design means the price is extremely low, but—thanks to its perfect shape—it still manages to provide excellent targeted prostate stimulation. Talk about “bang for your buck”! That said, the Booty Buddy isn’t a good option for people who want advanced features like vibrations or thrusting. Instead, I’d recommend this toy to people who want an item that can be enjoyed in the shower (or any other water-centric location!). Never tried an anal toy before, curious, but not willing to invest a lot of money? If so, I recommend picking up the Booty Buddy. Satisfaction doesn’t need to cost more than $20. After all, its low price point in the reason I selected it as my top “cheapest” pick!

Beginner prostate toys often suffer from one of two scenarios: they’re either fully waterproof but lack vibration functions, or have vibrations but aren’t completely waterproof. Fortunately, the Helix Syn V manages to be completely waterproof while also offering eight unique vibration patterns, which easily earned it my recommendation! However, I wouldn’t say that it’s the best prostate massager for beginner users, mainly due to the location of the controls. Both the control buttons and the charging port are located toward the bottom of the device. This means you’ll have trouble adjusting during use, and the port may get wet in the meantime. Fortunately, these aren’t major issues, but you should still be aware of them. If you can live with these two minor shortcomings then I strongly recommend considering the Helix Syn V.

As a beginner prostate toy, the nJoy Pure Wand is a bit expensive. At nearly $150, I definitely recommend putting some thought into this purchase. It doesn’t offer any vibration functions, which is something that people often want in a prostate toy for beginners. However, if you don’t care about that then the Pure Wand might be worth it. It can be used as either a beginner prostate massager or as a g-spot dildo; the stainless steel is perfect for temperature play, and it’s also completely waterproof. Still, with one end sized  for beginners, one sized for the more experienced, the ability to be sterilized, and total compatibility with every type of lube, it’s a compelling option. The Pure Wand might not be for everyone, but—for those who just want a temperature-play capable toy that can satisfy on land and in water—it’s definitely a great toy for those willing to give it a try!

The Tracey Cox Beaded Prober is a relatively straightforward toy: what you see is exactly what you get! Most of the stimulation this toy offers is enjoyed while inserting or removing the toy, making it an excellent way to enhance your orgasms. However, the toy isn’t quite as promising for constant stimulation (although it can still accomplish this). The main appeal is the variety of bead sizes, which allow the toy to be enjoyed by nearly any experience level. If you’re looking for a budget and beginner-friendly option that’s easy to use and easy to clean, this sub-$20 toy is worth adding to your collection!

As a beginner prostate massager, the Tantus Charmer works quite well. It’s designed with four ridges along the shaft, which adds an extra layer of stimulation to the insertion/removal process. The girth also varies slightly along the shaft, further enhancing the experience. Although the majority of users love using this toy, a few did notice that it wasn’t quite as hard as they’d have liked. Fortunately, unless you’re looking for a rock-hard toy, this is unlikely to be an issue! At around $50, the Tantus Charmer isn’t exactly cheap, but it’s not expensive either. Considering the various ways this toy can be used (and the fact that it’s made from high-quality silicone), I definitely think the Charmer is worth the modest investment! From an excellent build quality to its ridged, manageable shaft design, the Tantus Charmer easily keeps up with the high expectations set by other Tantus toys, making it a shoo-in for the dildo category.