The 7 Best Heart Butt Plugs for a Romantic Rear

   Isabelle Uren
In this review, you’ll find the very best heart butt plugs for all tastes and budgets! I’ve got everything from cheap heart butt plugs for those on a budget to a luxury vibrating heart shaped butt plug. I also found some great sets with multiple sized plugs for you to play with! And, if you aren’t quite sure what to look for, I’ve added a handy heart butt plug buying guide at the end of the post!
1 Test Winner

Lovehoney Jeweled Heart Metal Butt Plug

 Lovehoney Jeweled Heart Plug

  • Love sleek metal plugs
  • Are a butt plug beginner
  • Want to explore temperature play

Lovehoney Jeweled Heart Plug

  • Prefer a silicone plug
  • Are more experienced with anal play
  • Prefer a bigger base

You partner won’t be able to resist your cutie booty with this pink heart gem butt plug! The bulb shapes creates a delicious sensation of fullness while the heart base keeps the plug safely anchored outside your body. Made from metal, the plug is lovely and smooth and is perfect for exploring temperature play!

  • Beginner-friendly size
  • Smooth metal
  • Suitable for temperature play
  • Bulbed shape for a full feeling
  • Compatible with all lubes

  • Too small for those with more experience
  • Base could be a little bigger
Lovehoney Jeweled Heart Plug
Length3 inches
Insertable length2.5 inches
Diameter1.1 inches

This jewelled heart butt plug was a clear winner thanks to it’s cute design, great price, and approachable size! While the plug is a beginner-friendly size, the bulb shape still provides a satisfyingly full feeling for anyone new to anal play. It might however be a little underwhelming for those with more experience. The only thing I would improve with this plug is making the heart base just a little bigger for safety and peace of mind.

2 Cheapest

PinkCherry I Love You....Butt Red Heart Anal Plug

 PinkCherry I Love You....Heart Plug

  • Are looking to size up from beginners toys
  • Have some experience with anal sex
  • Prefer metal anal plugs

PinkCherry I Love You....Heart Plug

  • Are totally new to anal play
  • Prefer a soft, silicone plug
  • Want a vibrating plug

Channel the Queen of hearts with this racy red heart jewel butt plug! This sleek metal plug measures 1.25 inches in diameter making it a perfect plug for those with some anal experience. You can use any lube you like with this plug and you can even warm it or cool before use for some teasing temperature play.

  • Smooth metal slides easily
  • Bulbed shape feels filling
  • Compatible with all lubes
  • Can be heated or cooled

  • Some found the base too small
  • Might be too big for complete beginners
PinkCherry I Love You....Heart Plug
Length3.25 inches
Insertable length2.5 inches
Diameter1.25 inches

You’d be hard pressed to find a cheaper heart butt plug that’s still great quality! While it might be a little big for anyone new to anal play of any kind, if you’ve had a little experience, this plug should be a great fit! Although this is slightly bigger than the test winner, the tapered shape ensures that it’s still easy to insert, and the red heart will look super cute peeking out from between your cheeks!  

3 Beginner

First Time Fun Crystal Booty Duo Set

 Crystal Booty Duo Set

  • Want two different sized plugs
  • Prefer silicone to metal
  • Love the cute pink look

Crystal Booty Duo Set

  • Prefer bigger plugs
  • Want to explore temperature play

Unlock your inner princess with this sweet duo of silicone butt plugs with heart gems! With two different size plugs, you can start with the smaller, beginner-friendly one and work your way up to the bigger one or share the set with a partner. Each silicone plug is topped with a perfect pink heart gem that sparkles as you move your booty!

  • Two different sized plugs
  • Lovely soft silicone
  • Rounded tip for comfort
  • Cute heart gem base

  • Will be underwhelming for more experienced users
  • Rounded tip more difficult to insert than tapered tip
Crystal Booty Duo Set
Insertable lengthSmall: 2.5, Large: 3.2 inches
DiameterSmall: 1.1, Large: 1.4 inches
Materials Plug: silicone, Gems: acrylic

This silicone butt plug set is great if you prefer a softer, more flexible plug to a rigid metal one. The size is definitely better for beginners or anyone who enjoys a smaller toy, and I love that you can start with the smaller one before moving onto the bigger one! The rounded ends can be more comfortable to wear in different positions as they won’t stick in as much as a tapered end. This does make them a little more difficult to insert though, so you might want to warm up with a finger or two.

4 Vibrating

b-Vibe Vibrating Heart Plug

 b-Vibe Vibrating Heart Plug

  • Are looking for a medium sized plug
  • Want a vibrating heart plug
  • Prefer remote controlled toys

b-Vibe Vibrating Heart Plug

  • Are totally new to anal play
  • Are on a budget
  • Aren't bothered about vibrations

Beauty and the buzz! This heart butt plug from B-Vibe packs some powerful vibrations to tingle your tush and with 6 speeds and 15 patterns, there’s plenty to explore! You can control the settings using the remote or hand it over to your partner and let them take control from up to 30 feet away. The plug has a nice taper so it slips in easily and measures 1.45 inches at it’s widest point, putting it in the medium size range. If you’re looking for something more challenging, it’s also available in M/L version.


  • Powerful vibrations
  • Remote control
  • Long battery life
  • Travel lock
  • Available in S/M and M/L

  • Pricey
  • Splashproof but not waterproof
  • Too big for anyone new to anal play
b-Vibe Vibrating Heart Plug
Vibration speeds6
Vibration patterns15
Length3.85 inches
Insertable length3.1 inches
Diameter1.45 inches
Battery Life90 minutes
Charging Time90 minutes
Travel LockYes
Storage Bag IncludedYes

While a lot of butt plugs are weak and buzzy, this vibrating butt plug really delivers in terms of power and vibration quality, while still being quiet enough to be discreet! Unfortunately, that quality does come at a price and this is quite the investment, but if you love cute butt plugs and want a remote control option, this is a fantastic plug. Our tester, Emily, loved how much extra stimulation this plug added to partnered sex and how much it intensified her orgasms. She was also super impressed with the thoughtful extras that came with the plug, like the anal play guidebook and storage bag! While this is listed as a small/medium it is definitely more of a medium and is likely to be a little big for complete beginners, so keep that in mind when deciding if this is heart shaped butt plug for you.

5 Set

Booty Sparks Pink Heart Plug Set

 Booty Sparks Pink Heart Plug Set

  • Want a training set
  • Prefer metal butt plugs
  • Want to try temperature play

Booty Sparks Pink Heart Plug Set

  • Only want one plug
  • Prefer silicone or flexible plug

Take your butt on pleasure journey with this heart butt plug set. The kit contains three different sized plugs for you to slowly progress through. The small measures just 1 inch in diameter and 2.4 inches insertable length, making it perfect for beginners who want to work up to bigger things! The large measures a juicy 1.5 inches in diameter and 3.4 inches in insertable length, giving you a satisfying stretch to look forward to! The plugs are made of smooth sleek metal that feels fantastic when heated or cooled in water before use!

  • Three sizes to explore
  • Perfect for anal training
  • Suitable for temperature play
  • Filling bulbed shape

  • Might not be big enough for more experienced users
Booty Sparks Pink Heart Plug Set
LengthSmall: 2.8, Medium: 3.2, Large: 3.7 inches
Insertable lengthSmall: 2.4, Medium: 3, Large: 3.4 inches
DiameterSmall: 1, Medium: 1.3, Large: 1.5 inches
MaterialsAluminium alloy

This set really puts a cute twist on anal training kits! It’s a great option for anal play newbies who wants to slowly build up to anal sex or using bigger anal toys. The small size is really non-intimidating and a great way to get accustomed to anal plugs. However, if you are looking for an anal training kit for more experienced users who want a challenge, this isn’t going to satisfy and you should look for something a little bigger! This is a little pricier than some of the other products in this review but when you consider you are getting three plugs, it’s actually very good value for money!

6 Candy Heart

Play With Me Naughtier Candy Hearts Silicone Butt Plugs

 Candy Hearts Silicone Butt Plugs

  • Have considerable anal play experience
  • Love the cheeky message
  • Enjoy silicone butt plugs

Candy Hearts Silicone Butt Plugs

  • Aren't comfortable with larger anal toys
  • Prefer a metal plug
  • Want a vibrating toy

Get cheeky with this candy heart plug that comes with a naughty message on the base that tells your partner exactly what you want them to do! Made of body-safe silicone, the plug features a finely tapered end to help the plug slip in easily. It measures 1.6 inches in diameter and 3 inches in insertable length so this one for those with more anal experience! Plus the plug is easy to clean and can even be boiled to be sterilised.

  • Sexy message on the base
  • Tapered tip for easy insertion
  • Body safe silicone

  • Difficult to clean lube out of the lettering
  • Pointed tip can be uncomfortable in some positions
Candy Hearts Silicone Butt Plugs
Length4.25 inches
Insertable length3.75 inches
Diameter1.75 inches

As this is one of the biggest plugs in this review, this is a really great option if you have some more anal play experience or are looking for a more intense stretch. The end is quite dramatically tapered to help with insertion but there is the possibility for it to dig in certain positions. I really love the nod to candy hearts and the cheeky message on the base but it can be difficult to clean out the lettering, so try not to get any lube in there.

7 Rainbow

Rear Assets Small Jeweled Rainbow Heart Butt Plug

 Rear Assets Rainbow Heart Plug

  • Love rainbow sex toys
  • Are new to anal play
  • Want a plug you can heat or cool

Rear Assets Rainbow Heart Plug

  • Have more anal play experience
  • Prefer flexible butt plugs

Ride the rainbow to pleasure town! It really doesn’t get any cuter than than rainbows and sparkly heart gems! This beautiful butt plug measures 1 inch at it’s widest point, making it a great first time butt plug. The aluminium slides easily with a slick of lube and holds temperature well for some tantalising temperature play.  

  • Fun rainbow design
  • Beginner-friendly size
  • Great for temperature play
  • Can be used with any lube

  • Too small for those with more experience
Rear Assets Rainbow Heart Plug
Length2.5 inches
Insertable length2 inches
Diameter1 inches
Storage Bag IncludedYes

I love the unique rainbow finish of this metal butt plug! It’s playful yet elegant at the same time! It’s a really great plug at a great price and it even comes with a storage bag! It’s pretty small so it’s more of a beginner’s butt plug and probably won’t satisfy those with a bigger appetite!

Other Novelty Butt Plugs with Adorable Aesthetics

If you love decorating your derrière but hearts aren’t for you, I’ve got some more beautiful butt plugs for you to choose from!

Lovehoney Star Power Jeweled Metal Butt Plug Set (3 Piece)

Lovehoney Star Power Jeweled Metal Butt Plug Set (3 Piece) - Other Novelty Butt Plugs with Adorable Aesthetics
Make your booty the star of the show with this glorious gold butt plug set from Lovehoney! The set includes three different size plugs for you to progress through or share with a partner. Plus, each one is topped with a star gem to make your backside sparkle and shine!

Master Series Booty Bloom Rose Butt Plug

Master Series Booty Bloom Rose Butt Plug  - Other Novelty Butt Plugs with Adorable Aesthetics
Let your booty bloom with this sensual rose butt plug from Master Series. The whole plug is made from smooth silicone, making it easy to clean and you can even boil it to sterilize it! This small plug is just 1.1 inches in diameter so it’s perfect butt plug beginners!

Playful Silicone Small Bunny Tail Butt Plug

Playful Silicone Small Bunny Tail Butt Plug - Other Novelty Butt Plugs with Adorable Aesthetics
Add a pop of playful pink to your posterior with this bunny tail butt plug! The plug is made from silicone and is the perfect size for butt play beginners. The tail is made from faux fur and as well as looking super cute, the fluffy design is great for teasing and tickling!

Tailz Pink Pony Tail Anal Plug

Tailz Pink Pony Tail Anal Plug - Other Novelty Butt Plugs with Adorable Aesthetics
Enjoy some pony play with this pretty-in-pink tail butt plug. The silicone plug is topped with a 20 inch synthetic tail that’s just perfect for swishing around seductively! The plug measures 1.3 inches in diameter, making it best for those with a little butt play experience.

What to look for in a heart butt plug

If you’ve fallen in love with the idea of a heart butt plug, but aren’t sure which one to choose, I’ve got a handy little buying guide for you right here!


Material - What to look for in a heart butt plug
It’s really important to choose a material that is non-toxix and non-porous, such as silicone, metal, ABS plastic, or borosilicate glass. Most heart butt plugs are made from silicone or metal. Silicone is flexible, making it more comfortable to move around it, whereas metal is rigid and can feel more intense. Metal plugs are better for exploring temperature play as they hold heat and cold better.


Size - What to look for in a heart butt plug
If you are new to butt plugs and anal play, I would suggest looking for a butt plug around 1 inch in diameter to start with. If you have some experience with penetrative anal play, you could look for a butt plug that’s 1.25- 1.5 inches in diameter. I’ve also written a whole guide to help you figure out which butt plug size you should buy.


Shape - What to look for in a heart butt plug
Thin torpedo-shaped butt plugs are easier to insert, but they are more likely to slip out. Butt plugs with a bulb shape and thin neck are better at staying in. They also provide more of filling sensation.


Vibrations - What to look for in a heart butt plug
You should also consider whether you want a heart butt plug that also vibrates for some extra sensation. If you do go for a vibrating plug, you should also think about whether you need a remote control. This can make it easy to change settings or even let you partner take control.

How to use a heart butt plug

Butt plugs are a great accessory for partnered or solo sex and they are pretty easy to use! Butt plugs themselves often don’t provide enough stimulation to reach orgasm, but they are a great addition to other partnered or solo play! They can also be fun to wear for some slow-building foreplay! Here are my top tips for using your heart butt plug but for more detailed instructions and inspiration, check out this post on how to use a butt plug.

Start with some foreplay

Start with some foreplay

Get yourself nice and aroused and then enjoy some anal-based foreplay by massaging and stroking the anus and taint. This will help you relax and prepare for inserting your plug.

Use plenty of lube

Use plenty of lube

If you are using a silicone plug, you should stick to water-based lube but if your plug is made from metal or glass, you can whichever lube you prefer. You can add lube to the plug and around your anus. You could also use a lube injector to insert lube inside your anus to keep you lubricated for longer.

Insert the plug slowly

Insert the plug slowly

When you are ready to insert the plug, take some deep breaths to help relax your brain and body and hold the tip against

Stimulate other erogenous zones

Stimulate other erogenous zones

How to clean a heart butt plug

Hygiene is of utmost importance when it comes to anal toys! You should clean your heart butt plug with water and sex toy cleanser or a mild, unfragranced soap before and after each use. If your heart butt plug has electrical components, such as vibrations, be sure to check that it's waterproof before submerging it in water.


If your heart butt plug is made from metal or glass, you can use any type of lubrication, but if it's made from silicone, you should only use water-based lubes.

If you are a beginner, I would opt from something around 1 inch in diameter. Those with some experience (e.g. if you have had anal sex before) could go for something between 1-1.5 inches in diameter.

All of the links in this review are for shops that we trust so you shop for any of the products with peace of mind! Some of the best shops to buy heart plugs include Lovehoney, SheVibe, PinkCherry and HustlerHollywood.

What is a heart butt plug?

A heart butt plug is a butt plug that has a heart shaped base to add a touch of cuteness to your anal play! Many also have a heart shaped gem for a little extra sparkle and shine! They tend to made of either metal or silicone and sometimes come in a set with multiple sizes for you to progress through.

: $0







heart shaped butt plug, butt plug heart, heart jewel butt plug, glass heart butt plug, purple heart butt plug, heart gem butt plug, butt plug with heart, diamond heart butt plug, crystal heart butt plug,