6 Best Penis Extenders

I didn’t pick out the Lovehoney Mega Mighty 2 as the Test Winner because it’s the biggest penis extender in this review. I picked it because I think it’s a great all-rounder. With a total length of 7.5″ and a diameter of 2″, I think it will cater to most average-sized erections, adding just the right amount of extension and girth. The realistic design is impressive in terms of the texture. The raised veins and the pronounced head provide some extra stimulation for you partner. Our tester, Josh, really liked the clear design since it “offers you a more unique view of your cock actually wearing a toy, and allows you and your partner to still see your boner even though it’s covered by a large extender.” The sleeve itself is quite thick which actually makes it possible to use with a partial erection. Despite it being “fairly weighty for a toy that is to be supported by your penis”, Josh found that the ball loop was easy to use, and kept the Lovehoney Mega Mighty in place nicely.

The Lovehoney Mega Mighty 3 is a really close Runner-Up as it’s almost identical to the Test Winner, just with a few extra inches to play with! This penis extender has about 3 extra inches to offer in length. It also has that realistic design with added texture for your partner, and a lot of different colors to choose from. This penis extender offers a whole lot of bang for your buck. Josh also tested this one for us so we could get a proper comparison from him. Even though it’s similar in design, he noted as those 3 inches “really does make all the difference.” Thanks to the soft and flexible soft plastic, it is “comfortable to wear, and feels pretty lifelike.” The main and most obvious drawback is that “it provides far less stimulation for the person wearing it than the person on the receiving end of it.” This, on the other hand, can be a pro if you want to delay orgasm and your overall playtime.

The Perfect Fit: Fat Boy Thin Sheath 4.0 is super stretchy and designed to fit comfortably around most small to average sized erections. Because of its subtle design that doesn’t add too much length or girth, I think this is a great option for anyone beginners who just want to experiment. As our tester, James, said in his review: “If you’re proud of your natural size and just want to spice things up, this toy is your spicy sidekick – give it a whirl!” The interior texture is a nice feature so both partners get to enjoy the penis extender. The only thing to keep in mind is that it requires a lot of lube to keep things gliding smoothly in there. I also wouldn’t recommend this particular version to someone who has a much longer than average penis. The material is very stretchy but it is only about 4 inches long. According to James, this simple penis extender may not look like much, but it’s both affordable, easy to use, and feels impressive: “Personally, I’m head over heels for how it looks and feels during intimate moments with my partner. And, let me tell you, the intense orgasms from my partner are like a standing ovation.”

I selected the Vixen Colossus as my Expert Pick because it is THE best penis extender, in my humble opinion. It’s made of high quality, platinum-cured silicone, which makes it not only more durable and long-lasting, but also easy to keep clean and sterilize. However, I recognize that it is a luxury item and has a price tag that fits that label. So, it’s probably not a great all-rounder, but for those who want to splurge on a premium penis extender, it’s perfect! The design is also very impressive with the hyper-realistic details and the pronounced head to provide some stimulation for your partner. Our tester, Jeremy, did note that the tip can feel a bit overwhelming for the receiver because of the size. Be sure to warm up! “I knew after my first use that the Colossus would be rated very highly. The Colossus was easy to put on, comfortable to wear, and had a nice, textured inside for stimulating the penis during intercourse.” Since the sleeve is so thick and sturdy, Jeremy pointed out that it “performed well, whether with a full or partial erection”. I appreciate when penis extenders can still work without a full erection since the penis sometimes doesn’t experience a lot of sensation through the sleeve.

The Fantasy X-Tensions Uncut Penis Enhancer is a great option for anyone who likes the look or feel of an uncut penis. This sleeve will give you a slight boost in girth and has a hole at the tip of the sleeve so you can still have a realistic ejaculation experience. The realistic sleeve is made of silicone, so it’s completely body-safe and easy to sterilize between uses. Our tester, Peter, found that it was “a little tight but fits nicely” and stays in place very well. The soft sleeve offers a nice sensation for the wearer, as “it slides back like real foreskin”. Because of the design that’s meant to enhance your natural penis size rather than extend it, this isn’t the penis extender to opt for if you’re looking for a few extra inches in the tip. It’s more of an accessory to turn your own penis into an uncut one!

Our tester, James, really enjoyed the Perfect Fit The XPlay Breeder. It’s one of our best open-tip penis extenders that “lets you enhance your girth while still finishing outside the sleeve”. It’s made of soft and stretchy SilaSkin (TPE blend) so it’s definitely not as durable or easy to clean as silicone. Still, it’s comfortable to wear and stretches to fit a lot of penis sizes: “If you’re average-to-large, this sleeve will fit like a dream. But if you’re smaller, it might be a bit too roomy.” While James found that the interior texture is a bit subtle, “once you’re wearing it, the tightness and exposed head still deliver some fantastic sensations.” Both he and his partner has an amazing experience with the enhanced penetration. Keep in mind that the material is not compatible with latex, so latex condoms or any other gear isn’t a great idea. Although, with the open-tip design (and the product name), I’m assuming a condom will be counterintuitive.