The 5 Best Tail Butt Plugs

The DOMINIX Deluxe Tail Butt Plug was a very clear winner, as the best tail butt plug, especially when you consider “the quality for the plug, with the price point”, then it becomes “pretty hard to beat” as Mariah, who tested it, put it. She was “quite surprised at the weight of the plug in my hand” although she didn’t think 7 ounces sounded heavy she found the weight to “feel pretty darn good too”. As someone with a lot of experience with butt plugs, I can say that the added weight of metal butt plugs typically feels so much better during use. And, that’s also what we find is our testers experience. Mariah hadn’t tested a tail butt plug before, and found it “adorable”, and loved that it comes “in a handful of colors”. She also found that the long tail screws on/off, which “provide a quick clean up”, and essentially she found it gave her the “option of an entirely new toy sans tail to play with”. She did comment that the base isn’t polished, meaning it will look a bit weird when used without the tail.

The Dominix Deluxe Faux Fox Tail is a close second to the test winner. They are actaully very similar, with only the tails being a different design. While I really like the big bushy fox tail, I felt the black tail was a bit more versatile and sexy. Victoria tried it out for us and was “absolutely thrilled” with it! She found “the medium size is a good size—not too intimidating, but enough to provide that satisfying feeling”. I like that you could use this without having to do too much warm up, while the weight increases the sensation. The tail is “soft, fluffy, and looks amazing” and has a good length to it for swinging around or giving a tug on. Victoria also loved the role play element, commenting she had “always been curious about pet play, and this tail made it so much fun!” I really value an easy clean up, so appreciate that the tail twists off for easy cleaning. Victoria did note, however, that it’s tricky keeping the tail free of lube during use.

At around the $30 mark, this fluffy bunny tail is my top pick that is still high quality but more budget-friendly! Our tester Kasia wrote that the cute pink tail “absolutely stole my heart,” and I can really see why! She summed her experience up as “easy, comfortable, and fun,” commenting “I love how it looks when I am wearing it, and so does my partner.” The plug is a nice beginner-friendly size and the “tapered tip makes everything go smoothly” for an easy insertion. Even though it’s made of zinc alloy and not stainless steel, it’s still great quality and has a “weighty feel” that adds enhances the sensation. My one complaint with this tail butt plug is that the tail is not detachable, which makes cleaning a little more difficult.

Isabelle, who tested her first tail butt plug with this very extensive set for us, said “the pink bunny tail looks the best” to her, but that her “partner really enjoyed the overall look” of the two longer tails. Even though she was initially “more interested in the longer tails” as well, they ended up being too “thick and bulky rather than cute and sexy”. Although she “enjoyed the dressing up/role play” aspect, they did experience some difficulties with the set. First, changing between the different tails proved to be “a little tricky”, and in fact, the attachment for the tails broke off. But, Isabelle was quickly “able to super glue the base back on”. This did make he think of “the quality [as] mediocre at best”, and she actually thinks “the price would be very good considering you get a remote control butt plug and three different tails.” In terms of the vibrations in the plug, she said they were “a little buzzy” but actually “very quiet”. The last thing I’ll note from her review is that she found it “doesn’t state whether the plug is waterproof”, so in my expert opinion, you should simply assume it isn’t. Overall considering the price, you get a ton of versatility with this plug. Making it a fantastic starting point for any beginner.

So far my picks have been nice and cutesy, but I wanted to include something naughty as well! Allen reviewed it for us and was very impressed to get such “a stellar find at such a cheap price point”. Being such a large toy made of body safe silicone, the “Devil Tail Anal Plug gives you alot for a little.” He wrote that “it felt wonderful” to use, in particular the “overwhelming feeling of fullness was great”. I think the ruler markings are great for tracking your depth training progress as well! Overall, the slim diameter and the soft, flexibility make it “easy toy to use” but can it be “a bit hard to hold onto when it was all lubed up” so I recommend keeping some wipes or a cloth on hand!