The 8 Best Butt Plug Sets to Work Your Way Up to Amazing Anal

This butt plug training kit is designed with the complete beginner in mind. For that demographic, it works perfectly. Admittedly, the price is a bit high, but we think that—for the convenience and extra educational information—this slight premium is justified. The anal plug kit contains three different plugs in three different sizes, each made from silicone. Unfortunately, there aren’t any color or alternative sizing options offered. However, the included sizes should be fine for newcomers. If you fall into the target demographic for this butt plug kit then we highly recommend picking it up! On the other hand, if you’ve experimented with anal play before then you may be better off going with a different kit that offers plugs in larger sizes.

The Mood Naughty 1 butt plug set is a good option for a first-time anal player who already has some basic sex toy equipment on hand. The kit is priced very affordably, giving you three high-quality plugs for less than $50. You also have two color options to choose from, which is a positive as it’s always nice to have options. However, this butt plug starter doesn’t come with any extras. You won’t get a lube applicator, and you won’t get any lube like you might with other butt plug sets. Still, if you already have these things on hand then there’s no need to pay for them twice. If you already have everything you need (sans the plugs themselves) then this kit of trainer butt plugs offers an affordable way to start out with anal play!

The main selling point of this butt plug training kit is the fact that each plug is handblown using borosilicate glass. Worried about the glass breaking? No need: borosilicate glass is completely safe for anal use! Aside from the fact that the plugs in this butt plug kit can be used with any type of lubricant (which is already a huge win for those who love silicone lube), the option to enjoy temperature play may be enticing. Since the glass is extremely temperature sensitive, you can use this anal plug kit to enjoy chilled or heated sensations on top of the pleasures of anal penetration. Sure, it might not have any additional features like vibrations, but we definitely think that temperature play enthusiasts will love these plugs.

Like many Lovehoney products, this butt plug set is a good option for beginners and intermediate anal enjoyers. The smallest plug measures 1.11” across; the largest has a width of 1.59”. This difference in sizing should give buyers a long time to enjoy these trainer butt plugs, assuming they don’t intend to go to larger sizes right away. The faux jewels themselves are a nice touch, although it would be nice to see some color options here. Still, if jeweled is the look you’re going for then this option is preferable to other butt plug sets. Like the previous option, these metal plugs can also be used for temperature play, though within a smaller range of temperatures (you don’t want to melt the jewel!). Overall, for less than $60, we think this set offers a nice aesthetic and good value for the money.

The majority of feedback we were able to find for this butt plug kit was positive. In fact, only one person was left dissatisfied (their main complaint was the small size). As such, we wouldn’t recommend this anal plug kit to more experienced users. However, if you’ve never used a butt plug training kit or other type of anal toy before, you shouldn’t run into any sizing issues. Although modest, the design and shape of this toy are what really make it perform. It is made of ABS plastic. This isn’t ideal (as ABS isn’t completely non-porous) but it is a better option than PVC. Priced at less than $25, the Aneros Peridise kit offers a great way to enjoy stronger orgasms during routine sexual encounters while also getting some anal experience at the same time.

As a butt plug starter set, the Bumper Booty Bundle really shines. The butt plug set offers various toys within a small range of sizes, which is ideal for complete beginners. However, if you’ve previously used a butt plug set before, you will likely find that the toys included in this kit are a bit too small. Most kits with trainer butt plugs go larger than the plugs included in this kit, making the Bumper Booty Bundle a poor choice for those who have already started anal training. That said, this butt plug set does offer an excellent value for the money. With four toys, a bullet vibe, and an anal douche included, you’ll only need to grab a little lube before giving this kit a test run!

As noted by our tester, this butt plug kit is ideal for beginners and those with smaller anatomy. Maxing out at a width of 1.25”, it certainly isn’t going to be a challenge for more experienced users, but it should be enough for most people to enjoy. The two-bulb plug will likely be the hardest to insert due to its non-tapered tip. The three-bulb plug will be slightly easier as it starts on a smaller size. The spiral plug should insert the easiest, although this is also the one most likely to fall out during intercourse. As you can see, this anal plug kit manages to offer a decent variety within a single package (at a cost of under $25, no less!). While it may not be the longest-lasting butt plug training kit—as you may outgrow it rather quickly—it does offer arguably the most variety of anal sensations you can find from a kit at this price point.

The biggest advantage that this butt plug set has over the competition is the sizing. Unlike other butt plug starter sets (which often top out at a maximum width of 1.25”), this kit of trainer butt plugs goes all the way up to 1.76”! Paired with the fact that these butt plug sets cost less than $50 a piece, you can easily see why we recommend them. You’ll get a kit that you can enjoy for a long time at an affordable price! That said, we do have one question: why do the plugs have suction cup bases? Sure, some people might use them, but the vast majority of people won’t bother dealing with this feature. While it doesn’t necessarily take away from the plugs, we feel they would’ve been better off going with a t-bar base instead for increased long-term-wear comfortability.