5 Best Butt Plug Sets

I love the simple, classic design of these butt plugs. I’m sure if you close your eyes and think of butt plugs, this is what comes to mind! I gave it the top spot because they are simple and effective and offer quality at a reasonable price! They were a big hit with our reviewer, Peter, who wrote, “Both me and my partner found all three to be great fun and a perfect combination to add a little sparkle to our play time.” He found that the “plugs are very well made with a super silky finish” and the bulbed shape and thin neck mean they “stay in place during most activities.” I like that they’ve chosen to size up just 0.25 inches in diameter from the small to medium for a gentle increase and 0.5 from the medium to large for more of a noticeable difference.

I was the lucky tester of the Biird Regii Butt Plug Set and was thoroughly impressed with the quality and design at such an affordable price! They definitely don’t feel cheap at all. The silicone is velvety soft and they even come in their own matching blue velvet storage case. I also love the asymmetrical T-bar base design as it means the base doesn’t get in the way of vaginal penetration. I also prefer T-bar bases to round ones because I find them more comfortable to wear, especially for longer periods of time. They also stay put really well and don’t slide out! My partner, who was very new to anal play, actually tried out the small plug and found it a great size for him. It’s a shame there are only two sizes but at this price, I can’t really complain!

I chose this set as the best vibrating butt plug set as it offers variety in size and stimulation while still being reasonably priced. With two larger vibrating plugs and a small non-vibrating plug, there’s a butt plug for every occassion! Dani tried them out for us and wrote, “I love these beginner anal trainer plugs.” His favorite plug was the medium as it “is a nice size to not stretch too much but still give the sensation of having something there.” He also enjoyed the large as “will really make you fill full down there,” although it was a bit too large for longer sessions. I also really like that the shape of the base and thin neck make these comfortable for extended use. The plugs are very tapered, which makes them “very easy to slide into place with just a little lube.” Although he liked that the “vibrations are fairly quiet” he did wish that they were a bit stronger as they were on the weaker side.

This really is the Rolls Royce of butt plug sets. I chose it as the expert pick because although it is fantastic, it is also pricey and more than the average person might need. This is one for the anal toy connoisseurs who only want the very best for their booty! Our tester, Aaron, was equally as impressed! He wrote: “It’s easy to see the amount of consideration and passion that went into this.” b-Vibe really cover all bases in this kit, not only are the butt plugs fantastic quality, but there’s a range of sensations, including weighted and vibrating, and the kit comes with some really valuable extras. The educational book might not seem like such a big deal but even Aaron, who is more experienced with anal play, thought it was “very thorough, and full of valuable information.” Now onto the plugs themselves! The smallest plug is “very easy and convenient to use,” making it very beginner-friendly. The medium plug has an impressive number of settings to explore. In the large plug, the “weight isn’t exactly heavy, but it is noticeable.”   The only bit of the kit that Aaron wasn’t sold on was the lube applicator. I also had one in the b-Vibe kit I reviewed, and I have to say, it doesn’t really get much use, so I’d have to agree. Aside from that, I think that everything in this training kit is spot on!

A lot of butt plug sets and anal training kits are aimed at beginners but this one takes things up a notch and the biggest plug is enough to give most experienced users a stretch! George, who’s already experienced in anal play, found the small “barely noticeable” and the medium pleasant and manageable, but described the large “was a challenge.” Although there is an equal step up in size (10 mm in diameter) from the small to the medium and medium to large, the large is almost 2 inches in diameter and there is no denying that that is BIG! Plus, it is 0.8 inches longer, meaning there’s more of it to insert! While this could be challenging, I think this is a great set for those looking to work up to bigger toys! On top of that this butt plug set “has a quality feel” and importantly “stays in place once inserted,” so you can enjoy moving around without fear of it popping out! George also liked that they had “a nice, reassuring weight to them” that added to the overall experience.