The 6 Best Fisting Lubes for a Fist-astic Time

I chose this fisting lube as my “Test Winner” because it’s the all-around best lube for fisting. As one would hope, it’s safe for both vaginal and anal fisting. However, the biggest advantage that this cream has over other products is the ingredients used to make it. Combining water and silicone lubricant with coconut oil and shea butter, this fisting lube provides excellent lubrication with a creamy feel. It’s important to note that this lube isn’t clear, which could be a plus—or a minus—to some. It’s also closer to lotion than regular lube, which can get a bit messy during use. The lube does tend to dry out a bit faster than other products, but it does an excellent job as long as you’re using enough lube If you’re looking for a product that’s nice on the skin, vegan-friendly, and fairly priced then I think the Doc Johnson TitanMen Triple Duty Fisting Cream is worth checking out!

You might be wondering why this product earned the “Cheapest” mention on this list. Well, that’s simple: you can pick up a lubettte (0.17 oz) packet for only $1! To be fair, the larger sizes are a bit more expensive. Still, I really appreciate the fact that this lube is offered in multiple sizes, as these options are often overlooked by other brands. While it might not be the all-around best lube for vaginal fisting or anal play, this lube is still effective enough to be used as a fisting cream. The lube is long-lasting, easy to apply, and gentle on the skin, making it a solid option for most types of play. It’s even vegan-friendly, so there aren’t any lifestyle limitations to speak of! I’d definitely recommend at least giving this lube a try. If you’re not ready to commit to a full-sized 8.5-ounce bottle, SLiquid also offers this lube in 2 oz. and 4 oz. bottles (as well as the 0.17 oz. lubette packets)!

As my number one choice for “Water-Based Cream”, the Tantus Fisting & Masturbation Cream has high standards to uphold. Fortunately, as one of the best fisting lube products, it does so with ease! The main selling point of this product is that it’s safe to use with premium silicone sex toys. This is great, as many of the best lube for anal fisting products can actually damage your favorite toys. Beyond being silicone sex toy-safe, this cream also excels at providing a superior experience. This product is perfect for anal play and masturbation. Still, it is one of the best fisting lube products if anal play is your endgame. Vegan-friendly, only slightly pricier than alternative options, and silicone-safe, I think the Tantus Fisting & Masturbation Cream provides good value for the money.

I selected this fisting lube as my “Oil Based” recommendation for a few different reasons, but let’s go over the downsides first. Boy Butter isn’t latex-safe, which means you can’t use it with latex toys, props, or condoms. It’s also only offered in two sizes, a limitation that may not be ideal. However, aside from these two downsides, pretty much every aspect of Boy Butter is a positive one! As the best lube for fisting with an oil-based lube, Boy Butter provides an excellent, friction-free, and long-lasting lubrication experience. You can use it for anal play, vaginal play, or masturbation. No matter your needs, Boy Butter can step up to the plate. It’s easy to clean, won’t stain your clothes, and can even double as a massage oil. It can also be used with polyurethane condoms, meaning you can still be protected. Ultimately, if you don’t mind being limited to polyurethane condoms then Boy Butter is a great option. However, if you want to stick with latex condoms then Boy Butter might not be the best option.

Out of all the various options I’ve considered, Gun Oil came out as the best lube for vaginal fisting that’s “Silicone-Based”. However, the main reason you may not be interested is the price tag, which can extend up to $50—or beyond—per bottle! Is this fisting cream worth the asking price? Well, that’s up to you to decide, but I’d argue that it is. Being silicone-based, this lube won’t absorb into your skin, helping it last longer. It’s also received overwhelmingly positive reviews from customers, further proving its worth. If you decide to go for this lube, I’d recommend shopping around a bit for the best price (as they can vary widely). There are also a few different sizes of bottles offered, which could save you money as well. Beloved by customers and safe to use with condoms, Gun Oil might be a bit more expensive than some other lubes, but it’s nonetheless a product that I can confidently recommend.

Although this isn’t the best lube for anal fisting or even the best fisting lube in general, I still wanted to include Elbow Grease Original Cream on this list as an honorable mention. As a product that’s been around for a while, it’s amassed quite a large base of consistent and loyal customers. Of course, there’s a good reason for that: it works exactly as advertised! Being oil-based, it’s not suitable for use with latex condoms or toys. However, you can use it with polyurethane condoms, as well as non-latex, non-silicone toys. While this may limit it a bit in terms of potentially compatible toys, this shouldn’t present much of an issue when it comes to anal fisting. For fisting, Elbow Grease Original Cream works great. If you’re unsure which one of the options we’ve gone over so fast would work best for you, why not try something tried-and-true?!