The 7 Best Gay Masturbator Toys for Lifelike Anal Loving

I chose this anal male masturbator as my “Test Winner” for a few reasons, but the main one is that the toy itself is actually molded from a real model! A quick glance at the entrance of the sleeve shows a lot of detail. That’s because this part has been molded directly from Brent! You’ll also see his signature on the side, which is a nice touch. The toy is made from Fleshlight’s signature TPE blend. This means that it’s a very soft and high-quality material, although it’s worth noting that it is porous. Inside the sleeve, there is a combination of ribs and nubs to stimulate your shaft. This toy doesn’t offer as much variation as some other models, but it should be more than enough to get the job done. All in all, there really isn’t anything to complain about aside from the price (which hovers around $80). Compatible with a wide variety of Fleshlight accessories and molded from a well-known star, I’d say that this masturbator is an excellent addition to any collection of gay sex toys!

Being the most budget-friendly gay masturbator toy on this list, the THRUST Pro Mini Andi Super Ribbed Pocket Ass was the obvious choice for the “Cheapest” category. However, don’t let its cheap price tag or simple design fool you. Despite its looks, this toy actually punches well above its weight class! Internally, the THRUST Pro Mini Andi features rows upon rows of ribs, which provide consistent pleasure to your penis. However, it’s worth noting that this toy only has one texture, which could be a minus for some. The outside of the toy is also textured, making it easy to hold onto the toy while you’re using it. Unfortunately, the THRUST Pro Mini Andi doesn’t come with an external casing. This could make keeping the toy clean a challenge in the long term, so you’ll want to find something to store it in for safekeeping. All in all, this toy meets all the basic expectations that you’d need from a simple masturbator. While it might not offer the most premium experience and doesn’t come with the bullet vibe you’ll need to enjoy vibes, I think it still offers a fair value for the money.

The FleshSack is likely the only masturbator that you’ll ever see that comes complete with its own set of balls. If that’s your thing then you’re sure to love this toy! Even if you take the balls out of the equation entirely, the FleshSack still has enough quality to stand on its own. Rather than a single texture, the inside of this sleeve features five chambers with textures spread throughout. The dual-ended design of the toy makes it easy to clean, and the adjustable suction end cap means you can control the suction as you go. Surprisingly, the balls actually fit inside of the cap, meaning you won’t have to deal with the balls constantly getting dirty during storage. Sure, the balls may be a bit of a novelty, but they do offer a bit of extra stimulation when using the toy. If this unique design has caught your eye, pick one up and give the FleshSack a try!

For obvious reasons, I picked this gay masturbator toy as my “Ass” choice. Truly, this is all you need to have fun! The masturbator features two butt cheeks (each with a little leg), a partial back, a big pair of balls, and a tight hole for all of your penetrative pleasures. Internally, this toy is quite snug. Its closed-end design means you’ll be able to enjoy plenty of suction as you thrust in and out of the toy. All in all, the experience will feel pretty realistic! However, since this toy is bigger than a masturbator, it also weighs considerably more (close to eight pounds). Size-wise, it’s a little over 11 inches long and 9.25 inches wide. This means you’ll have to put a bit of space as to where you’ll store it, since simply shoving it into a drawer really isn’t an option. That said, I think these minor drawbacks are worth it if you’re after a more realistic masturbatory experience. Priced significantly less than similar toys and offering way more performance than a stroker, I’d recommend the Stroke It Bottom Banger if you want a toy to “practice” with!

This toy is much more than a simple anal male masturbator: it’s my “Torso” pick! Expensive, heavy, and offering a lot to work with, the Channing has a high bar to meet. Does it meet expectations? Well, it depends on who you ask. Our tester didn’t have much fun with it, citing a semi-soft penis and an extra tight anus as the reasons for his dissatisfaction. That said, this experience definitely isn’t universal, and most people appear to be happy with their doll. The penis is poseable, meaning it won’t be as firm as you may be used to. The anus only has a diameter of 0.28 inches, so it might require lots of lube if you’re on the thick side. It’s also worth noting that the Channing weighs almost 40 pounds, which means using this toy can be quite the workout. Still, even with all of that, I think the Channing is a good option if you want a multi-purpose practice doll. It also serves as a good stand-in for a “threesome” with your partner. With over seven inches of loving and highly textured anus to offer, Channing could be the much-loved addition that your sex toy collection is missing.

This gay masturbator toy earned the “Cock and Ass” mention because that’s exactly what it is! With a six-inch penis out front and six inches of insertable length inside, the Mr. Switch is a fairly straightforward sex toy. Internally, the tunnel features a variety of textures, including ribs and bumps spread across multiple internal chambers. Weighing a mere 5.56 pounds, this toy can easily be positioned to fulfill any of your sexual desires. The main place where I think this toy is lacking is the details. While it does have all of the parts you’d expect, some parts of the toy—specifically the penis—seem to be lacking finer details. I think the inclusion of these would do a lot to justify the price tag of nearly $150. All in all, I think the Mr. Switch is a pretty good dual-use toy: it’s just overpriced! While I would suggest picking this one up, I’d suggest keeping your eye out for a sale if you can.

The main limitation of this toy is the lack of options it offers. Being a “Side Saddle” anal male masturbator, you can really only use the toy in that single position. If this is your preferred position then no worries. However, if you were hoping for other options then you will be sorely disappointed. That said, the toy is pretty high-quality. It’s handpainted for the perfect finish, and features a lot of little details that help make it seem more realistic. I especially liked that you have the choice of three different skin tones, as many of these toys don’t give you this option. In summary, my thoughts are fairly straightforward. Love side saddle sex? Then this toy is worth picking up! Want more position options? Check out one of the other toys instead.